What Is the Tush Push? Why the NFL Just Refused to Ban It (Again)

Posted on by

In the ever-evolving chess match of NFL strategy, one play has emerged as both a weapon of dominance and a lightning rod for debate—the Tush Push. Popularized by the Philadelphia Eagles and feared by defensive coordinators across the league, this short-yardage quarterback sneak is now one of the most talked-about tactics in professional football.

And it’s not going anywhere.

Despite ongoing controversy and a formal vote this week, NFL owners refused to ban the Tush Push for the 2025 season, leaving fans and analysts divided—and coaches already drawing up their own versions of the unstoppable play.

🏈 What Exactly Is the Tush Push?

The Tush Push is a variation of the classic quarterback sneak—but with a powerful twist. On crucial short-yardage downs (like 3rd-and-1 or 4th-and-inches), the quarterback receives the snap and immediately plunges forward behind the center. What makes this different is that multiple teammates—usually tight ends or running backs—literally push the quarterback from behind, driving him past the line to gain.

While technically legal under current NFL rules, it feels more like a rugby scrum than traditional American football. The Philadelphia Eagles, with Jalen Hurts at quarterback and one of the league’s best offensive lines, turned the Tush Push into a virtually unstoppable tool in their 2022–2024 seasons.

🛑 Calls to Ban It Have Been Growing

Despite its efficiency, many coaches, players, and fans argue that the Tush Push violates the spirit of the game. Critics claim the play:

  • Creates unfair leverage that defenses can’t realistically counter

  • Increases the risk of injury in pileups

  • Undermines the complexity and creativity of offensive football

The NFL Competition Committee reviewed a proposal to ban the play during their spring 2025 meetings. But in the end, the motion failed—falling short of the 75% owner approval required to change league rules.

So, for now, the Tush Push remains perfectly legal.

✅ Why the NFL Said “Yes” to the Tush Push

Supporters of the play—and several prominent coaches—point to three key reasons why banning it would be a mistake:

  1. It’s legal under current rules. There’s no foul in pushing a ball-carrier forward unless other illegal elements are involved.

  2. It rewards execution and strength. The Eagles have shown it’s not as simple as it looks; few teams have replicated their success.

  3. Football is evolving. Just like the wildcat, RPOs, or zone reads, the Tush Push is a tactical innovation.

As one NFC executive told reporters anonymously:

“If your team isn’t strong enough to stop it, build a better defense. That’s football.”

🦅 The Eagles Made It Famous—Will Others Copy It?

Let’s be honest: the play would not be in the spotlight without the Philadelphia Eagles’ dominance. During the 2023 and 2024 seasons, they converted on Tush Push attempts at a staggering success rate—over 90% in some stretches.

Their ability to win short-yardage battles helped them control time of possession, extend drives, and dominate in the red zone. It even played a crucial role in their Super Bowl LVIII victory, fueling the movement to have it banned.

But now, with the play still legal, more teams are expected to adopt and adapt the Tush Push heading into 2025. Expect to see variations with fullbacks, motion setups, and possibly even fake-outs.

🚨 A Safety Concern—or a Smart Strategy?

The biggest pushback (pun intended) comes from those worried about player safety. Some argue that pushing from behind increases the risk of neck, back, or knee injuries—not just to the quarterback but to linemen caught in the pile.

However, the NFL’s health and safety review board found no significant increase in injuries related to the play compared to traditional short-yardage scrums. That, paired with its popularity, likely tipped the vote in favor of keeping it.

📣 What This Means for the 2025 NFL Season

With the Tush Push officially staying on the books, teams now face a choice: adapt or get left behind. Defensive coordinators will need to scheme better gap control and stack-the-box tactics, while offensive coaches may draw up creative new formations to disguise the play.

And the fans? They’ll keep debating.

Whether you see the Tush Push as a brilliant evolution of the quarterback sneak or a cheap hack that disrupts the balance of play, one thing is clear—it’s not going anywhere. Not this season, at least.

💡 Final Thought:

The NFL has always been a battlefield of brains and brawn—and the Tush Push sits right at that intersection. As the 2025 season kicks off, expect it to be one of the most talked-about plays on every Sunday highlight reel.